Revision as of 18:21, 3 December 2016

1. There is no mention of Hell in God’s Creation - therefore, Hell is uncreated by God or anyone else. See Ge 1:1, Is 65:17, Jer 7:31, Jer 19:5, Joh 1:3, and many instances of “heaven and earth” paired together – without “hell.”

Premise: There is no mention of Hell in God’s Creation

PI 1: There is no mention of Hell in God’s Creation

PI 1.1 Lit. Hell is either physical or heavenly in nature and is included in "heaven and earth".

PI 1.2 Alt. Hell is a third 'state' of existence: heaven, earth, hell

PI 2: There is no [specific] mention of Hell in God’s Creation.

Argument

Using only TRUE premises.

A-PI 2. There is no [specific] mention of Hell in God’s Creation.

therefore: Hell is uncreated by God or anyone else.

For A-PI 2 to be true both must be true:

A-PI 2.1There is no [specific] mention of Hell in God’s Creation.

therefore: Hell is uncreated by God

A-PI 2.2.1There is no [specific] mention of Hell in God’s Creation.

therefore: Hell is uncreated by anyone else. (self-existent)

A-PI 2.2.2There is no [specific] mention of Hell in God’s Creation.

therefore: Hell is uncreated by anyone else. (non-existent)

A-PI 2.1

A-PI 2.1 There is no [specific] mention of Hell in God’s Creation.

therefore: Hell is uncreated by God

Non-sequitor: A single case of something that was not specifically mentioned makes this false.

Non-sequitor: God could have created it AFTER the initial creation.

A-PI 2.2.1

A-PI 2.2.1There is no [specific] mention of Hell in God’s Creation.

therefore: Hell is uncreated by anyone else. (self-existent)

This presumes hell exists, and merely contradicts the conclusion that Hell does not exist.

A-PI 2.2.2

A-PI 2.2.2 There is no [specific] mention of Hell in God’s Creation.

therefore: Hell is uncreated by anyone else. (non-existent)

Non-sequiror: It could have been created as a state of existence by the act of separating from God by another individual. We may create hell for ourselves.